Lecture: “The author is everything”, but he doesn’t know everything: working with authors

LECTURE: ‘THE AUTHOR IS EVERYTHING’, BUT HE DOESN’T KNOW EVERYTHING: WORKING WITH AUTHORS

On Thursday, 26 November 2026, at 11.00 we invite you to an online lecture titled “The author is everything”, but he doesn’t know everything: working with authors. The lecture will be given by Prof. Dr. Jonatan Vinkler (UP FHŠ and UP UK). The event will be held in the Slovenian language via Zoom (https://upr-si.zoom.us/s/67802200737, Meeting ID: 678 0220 0737).

This lecture examines the asymmetric, dynamic relationship between authors (the author of the text, as well as secondary contributors such as designers, proofreaders, etc.), the editor, and the final publication within the contemporary publishing process. The central thesis is that while the author is, in a sense, “everything”—the source of the work’s content, identity, and authority—they do not necessarily master every aspect of the editorial, technical, and production-related tasks.

Consequently, the editor plays a pivotal, guiding role acting as a coordinator and conductor who ensures the coherence, clarity, and quality of the entire process.

1. Conceptual Framework: The Leitmotif as a Guiding Theme of a Publication

The lecture introduces the concept of the leitmotif as an analogical tool for understanding the author’s role. The term is derived from the German root Leit- (from the verb leiten—to lead, to direct) and the Latin motivus (from movere—to move, to prompt movement). Thus, a leitmotif denotes a recurring musical, visual, or literary theme that guides the recipient through a work, linking them to a specific character, object, emotion, or idea. Richard Wagner’s Der Ring des Nibelungen (The Ring of the Nibelung) is presented as an example, where leitmotifs provide both structural and semantic guidance, leading the listener through a complex, epic operatic narrative.

In the context of publishing, the author becomes the leitmotif of any given publication: a guiding element that lends the work coherence and distinctiveness, yet one that requires external direction.

2. Etymology and Meaning of the Term “Author”

The term “author” derives from the Latin auctor, a derivative of the verb augere (to increase, to grow, to cause growth). Its original meaning—”one who causes growth or brings about an increase”—gradually evolved to encompass “creator, originator, progenitor, builder, initiator, and advocate,” and, ultimately, “writer of a work.” The word “authority” also stems from this same root, emphasizing the “weight” and power of an author’s contribution. This etymological perspective underscores that while the author serves as the source of the content and identity of a publication, their role is not self-sufficient; it requires the professional support provided by the editorial process.

3. The Relationship Between Authors, the Editor, and the Publication

Central to this subject is the essential “holy trinity” of author, editor, and publication. This relationship forms a network of contributors, in which the roles are not equivalent—they differ in terms of power, duration, and orientation. Authors provide the core content, while the editor coordinates, delineates, and connects the various stakeholders into a coherent whole. Consequently, communication must always be functionally tailored to the specific needs of each interaction and the particular stage of the process. Such asymmetry necessitates a clear definition of boundaries and objectives to prevent misunderstandings and ensure efficiency.

4. The Editor’s Leading Role and Toolkit

The editor must actively lead the process, as the author cannot manage all the technical, scheduling, and organizational aspects on their own. The editor’s toolkit includes:

  1. defining, clarifying, and coordinating roles,
  2. delineating responsibilities,
  3. connecting stakeholders,
  4. setting meaningful goals with clearly defined quality, quantity, and timelines,
  5. acknowledging successful collaboration, and (when necessary)
  6. implementing corrective measures.

A key element is high-quality communication, which serves as a tool for the successful realization of a publication.

5. Principles of Quality Communication and Information

High-quality information must meet four criteria:

  1. subject matter (relevance of content),
  2. scope (appropriate quantity),
  3. timeliness, and
  4. appropriateness of communication.
    Communication with authors and collaborators must be:
  5. respectful (using appropriate forms of address),
  6. polite,
  7. economical (containing only essential information, without unnecessary explanations), and
  8. clear and unambiguous (covering WHAT, WHEN, BY WHEN, WHO, WHERE, WITH WHOM, and HOW—or IN WHAT FORMAT; avoiding metaphors and ambiguity).

Such communication ensures efficiency, prevents misunderstandings, and maintains a professional relationship within a complex publishing environment.

6. Specific Information for Key Stakeholders

The lecture precisely defines the information that each stakeholder must receive:

  • The author requires clear instructions regarding content, scope, deadlines, and the editor’s expectations, enabling them to align their contribution with the publication’s requirements.
  • The proofreader must be informed of style guidelines, linguistic standards, proofreading deadlines, the expected volume of text to be reviewed, and any specific requirements pertaining to the text.
  • The typesetter receives the formal design specifications (design plan) along with all relevant data, a digital template, the schedule for receiving text and supplementary materials, the timeline for proofing and final approval for print, and the final deadline for submission; they are also provided with contact details for the author, designer, proofreader, and printer.
  • The printer must be provided with precise technical parameters (extent of the book interior and cover, paper type, printing method, binding, finishing, and print run), the schedule for receiving materials, the timeline for reviewing and approving print-ready files, and the delivery date for the printed copies; additionally, they receive contact information for the editor and typesetter, as well as any specific requirements from the designer.

Conclusion

The lecture concludes by noting that a successful publication relies on clearly defined roles, effective leadership by the editor, and precise, tailored communication. While the author remains the driving force behind the work, it is the editor who guides and coordinates the process, bringing it to completion. Only in this way can a high-quality, coherent, and timely publication be ensured—one in which the author’s content reaches its full potential, while both costs and the timeline are kept under control.

Prof. Dr. Jonatan Vinkler is a specialist in the literary and cultural history of the early modern age, editor and librarian. Editor-in-chief of Collected Works of Primož Trubar and editor of the individual books of the mentioned scientific critical edition (2003–2018: the third, the fourth, the fifth, the sixth – with F. Kranjc-Vrečko, the eighth, the ninth – with B. Javornik and M. Šetinc, the twelfth, the thirteenth and the fourteenth book). He is the editor of a scientific critical edition of the Symphony in F major, opus 68: ‘Ljubljana transcript’, Ludwig van Beethoven with an international review in an indexed scientific journal (A&HCI, Scopus (h), ERIH PLUS …). On the reception of the Hussite and Lutheran Reformations, the imaginary of the ‘Turkish’ threat in the Slovenian cultural space and Czech-Slovenian and Slovene-Czech cultural and literary contacts in the century of ‘townspeople and revolutions’ he has published several single-authored scientific papers and monographs, which are cited in domestic and foreign scientific papers and monographs. Bibliography of dr. Vinkler has 360 units; he is the mentor of several doctoral students. He is the director of the University of Primorska University Library, chairman of the Board of Directors of the University of Primorska, and president of the National Council for Library Activities. He has received several awards for his work, among them the Prešeren Award of the FF UL (2000), the Trubar’s plaque of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in the Republic of (2017) and the Golden Plaque of the University of Primorska (2020).

Please pre-register for the event via LINK >>

This is the eighteenth lecture in the OSUP series – Open Science at the University of Primorska. The event is organised by the University of Primorska within the framework of the Action Plan for the Open Science (Objective 6.2 ReZrIS30) that is funded by the Government of the Republic of Slovenia, Ministry of Education, Science and Youth. If you have any questions you can contact Dr. Ana Slavec, the editor of the OSUP series. 

Past lectures that were organised within the OSUP series are available on the YouTube channel of the UP University Library >>

WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner